Amy Gumenick is an American actress. She had her career beginnings in the 2000s where she debuted in Army Wives. She later played the Young Mary Winchester in Supernatural. Afterward, she played the titular character in the made-for-television film Natalee Holloway. She reprised her role in Justice for Natalee Holloway. Since 2014, she has been playing the recurring role of Carrie Cutter / Cupid in Arrow. At the same time, she played recurring character Philomena Cheer in the AMC series Turn: Washington’s Spies. She went on to guest star in NCIS, as well as starred in the TV film False Profits.